Evidence against High Fructose Corn Syrup

Aug 04, 2008 Published under Health, Marketing

Over the last few weeks, the High Fructose Corn Syrup Lobby has begun a spin campaign to try to confuse consumers into thinking that HFCS is no different from other natural sugars, but studies including one from the University of Texas last week (and one from University of Florida three years ago) have confirmed that fructose causes fat build-up at unusually high levels and with unusually damaging consequences.

Fructose again linked to fat build-up: study

By Stephen Daniells

25-Jul-2008 – Fat build-up from fructose consumption may be greater than what occurs when we eat other types of sugars, such as glucose and sucrose, according to a new study.

Researchers from the University of Texas recruited six young, healthy, lean people to take part in their study, which compared the formation of fat (lipogenesis) following consumption of pure glucose, or combinations of glucose and fructose. 
The results are published in the Journal of Nutrition.
"Our study shows for the first time the surprising speed with which humans make body fat from fructose," said Elizabeth Parks from the UT’s Southwestern Medical Center.
"[Fructose, glucose and sucrose] can be made into triglycerides, a form of body fat; however, once you start the process of fat synthesis from fructose, it’s hard to slow it down," she added.
However, Dr Parks was quick to point out that it is misleading to suggest the consumption of a specific food or food ingredient was the cause of obesity and the rise of type-2 diabetes.
"There are lots of people out there who want to demonize fructose as the cause of the obesity epidemic," she said. "I think it may be a contributor, but it’s not the only problem. Americans are eating too many calories for their activity level. We’re overeating fat, we’re overeating protein; and we’re over-eating all sugars," she said.
Study details

Parks and co-workers recruited four men and two women with an average age of 28, and an average BMI of 24.3 kg per sq. m. The volunteers consumed three soft drinks on three separate occasions; one was sweetened with 100 per cent glucose, the second with 50 per cent glucose and 50 per cent fructose, and the third with 25 per cent glucose and 75 per cent fructose. The tests were random and blinded.
The UT researchers report that lipogenesis increased from 7.8 per cent for the glucose beverage, to 15.9 per cent after the 50:50 beverage and 16.9 per cent after the 25:75 beverage.
Moreover, blood triglyceride levels were between 11 and 29 per cent higher after consumption of the 50:50 and 25:75 beverage, compared to the 100 per cent glucose drink.
"The message from this study is powerful because body fat synthesis was measured immediately after the sweet drinks were consumed," said Dr. Parks said. "The carbohydrates came into the body as sugars, the liver took the molecules apart like tinker toys, and put them back together to build fats. All this happened within four hours after the fructose drink. As a result, when the next meal was eaten, the lunch fat was more likely to be stored than burned.

"This is an underestimate of the effect of fructose because these individuals consumed the drinks while fasting and because the subjects were healthy, lean and could presumably process the fructose pretty quickly. Fat synthesis from sugars may be worse in people who are overweight or obese because this process may be already revved up," she added.
Metabolism of fructose

The metabolism of glucose and fructose is different, said the researchers. In humans, triglycerides are predominantly formed in the liver. This organ decides what to do when it encounters glucose. The sugar is either stored as glycogen, burnt for energy or turn the glucose into triglycerides.
On the other hand, fructose bypassing the liver and floods the metabolic pathway, said the researchers.
"It’s a less-controlled movement of fructose through these pathways that causes it to contribute to greater triglyceride synthesis," said Parks. "The bottom line of this study is that fructose very quickly gets made into fat in the body."

The work was supported by the National Institutes of Health, the Cargill Higher Education Fund and the Sugar Association.
Well studied

Research from the University of Florida in 2005 reported similar results. In that instance the research implicated a rise in uric acid in the bloodstream that occurs after fructose is consumed. That temporary spike blocks the action of insulin, which typically regulates how body cells use and store sugar and other food nutrients for energy.
If uric acid levels are frequently elevated, over time features of metabolic syndrome may develop, including high blood pressure, obesity and elevated blood cholesterol levels.
"We cannot definitively state that fructose is driving the obesity epidemic," said researcher Richard Johnson, from UF’s College of Medicine Johnson, in 2005. "But we can say that there is evidence supporting the possibility that it could have a contributory role – if not a major role."
Source: Journal of Nutrition
June 2008, Volume 138, Pages 1039-1046
"Dietary Sugars Stimulate Fatty Acid Synthesis in Adults"
Authors: E.J. Parks, L.E. Skokan, M.T. Timlin, C.S. Dingfelder

Digg This
Reddit This
Stumble Now!
Buzz This
Vote on DZone
Share on Facebook
Bookmark this on Delicious
Kick It on DotNetKicks.com
Shout it
Share on LinkedIn
Bookmark this on Technorati
Post on Twitter
Google Buzz (aka. Google Reader)

related posts


  1. Obesity Epidemic - More Proof | Daniel Lubetzky said:

    [...] started growing at such steep pace, and it is no coincidence that 1980 is also the year when high fructose corn syrup was [...]

  2. Fructose and High Fructose Corn Syrup - More Evidence of the Harm they Cause | Daniel Lubetzky said:

    [...] spite of efforts by the High Fructose Corn Syrup Lobby to allege otherwise, more and more evidence is coming in linking it to the obesity and diabetes epidemics.  A new study [...]

  3. 18% tax on sugary drinks... - Page 4 - Order of the Blue Gartr said:

    [...] against HFCS Evidence against High Fructose Corn Syrup | Daniel Lubetzky __________________ [...]

  4. 18% tax on sugary drinks... - Page 4 - Order of the Blue Gartr said:

    [...] against HFCS Evidence against High Fructose Corn Syrup | Daniel Lubetzky Fruit is good for you in moderation, fruit juices is less so. Drink water most of the time some [...]

  5. W.H.Warrick III MD said:

    It causes fatty liver, diabetes and hypertension according to research in the nephrology department at Univ of Florida by Dr. Johnson. Fatty liver has become the most common liver disease in the past 30 years and is the #1 cause of liver transplant. It is poison and should be banned.

post a new comment